Reviews and Comments

Aaron

aaron@reads.caskey-demaret.se

Joined 10 months ago

This link opens in a pop-up window

The Terraformers (Hardcover, Tor Books) 3 stars

From science fiction visionary Annalee Newitz comes The Terraformers, a sweeping, uplifting, and illuminating exploration …

It's good it's just not compelling. And I really need something to pull me through the narrative right now. I might come back to it when I can read with more focus.

Witch King (EBook, 2023, Tom Doherty Associates, LLC) 4 stars

Kai-Enna is the Witch King, though he hasn’t always been, and he hasn’t even always …

Murder Demon

4 stars

The only other books by Martha Wells that I've read are the Murderbot Diaries, so it's pretty hard for me not to view it through that lens.

Which is unfair on the book, because it is entirely its own thing.

But also carries a lot of Murderbot DNA.

There's the conversational style, the same exasperated, hyper-confident protagonist with a prickly exterior but a heart of gold...

But Kai is also more openly vulnerable, more open with his friends and much more DTF.

Plot-wise it suffers from the same issues I have with the MBDs. The overarching story wasn't compelling, I don't really understand the stakes or the politics, at least not for the bulk of the book. So it was hard to get invested. But it doesn't matter because the whole thing is really just a framework to hang the individual set pieces on and, man, Wells is amazing on …

commented on Witch King by Martha Wells

Witch King (EBook, 2023, Tom Doherty Associates, LLC) 4 stars

Kai-Enna is the Witch King, though he hasn’t always been, and he hasn’t even always …

Nicely paced, an interesting world and the main character is likable.

However, it suffers from the same problem that the Murder Bot books do, in that the plot is kind of... superfluous. I don't really know what the point of it is, and I suspect that looking back, I won't remember either. This isn't a problem in MB because the main draw there is the characters, but this doesn't have that hook (at least not yet).

Also, Ziede sucks, I hope there is some character arc there, because right now I'm not a fan.